Discover strict Christmas lights rules that some families face. Learn why holiday decorations get fined and how to avoid legal troubles this season.
Strange Christmas Lights Rules That Can Cost You Money
Do you love putting up Christmas decorations? Many families do! But some people get big fines for their holiday lights. Why? Because of strict Christmas lights rules in their area.
Let’s learn about these rules and some surprising stories from around America.
Woman Gets Fine for Halloween Skeleton at Christmas
Alexis Luttrell lives in Germantown, Tennessee. She put up a big 8-foot skeleton for Halloween. The skeleton had a dog friend too. When Christmas came, she didn’t take them down. Instead, she made them festive!
She put a Christmas garland on the dog and a green-and-red tutu on the skeleton. It looked fun and creative.
But then something shocking happened. Her local government sent her a letter. They said she must remove her decorations or pay a big fine!
Why Did She Get in Trouble?
The city had a law about Christmas lights rules. The rule said:
- You can only put decorations up 45 days before a holiday
- You must take them down 30 days after the holiday
- Decorations must match the “right” holiday
Luttrell thought this was unfair. She said, “One person shouldn’t decide what Christmas decorations look like.”
The Big Fight Over Holiday Decorations
Luttrell didn’t give up. She got help from a special group called the Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression. They fight for people’s freedoms.
They took the case to court in February 2025. They said the city’s law was wrong because:
- It was too confusing
- It let government workers decide what decorations are “right”
- It stopped people from being creative
- It went against the First Amendment (freedom of expression)
Who Won?
Luttrell won! In April 2025, the city agreed to:
- Remove the bad law
- Cancel her fine
- Pay $24,999 to the legal group
Now her neighbors thank her for fighting. She keeps decorating her skeletons for every holiday – Valentine’s Day, Fourth of July, Pride Month, and more!
Christmas Lights Rules Around America
Luttrell’s story isn’t the only one. Many places have strict Christmas lights rules that families must follow.
Aspen, Colorado Has Strict Timing Rules
In Aspen, Colorado, people must follow these rules:
- Put up holiday lights after November 15 only
- Take down all lights by March 1
- Breaking the rule costs up to $2,500!
Sarah Sandifer works for the city. She says the law has been there for 15 years. Most people follow it. The city only checks when neighbors complain about lights staying up too long.
They get about 24 complaints each year. But they’ve never had to give anyone a fine yet.
HOA Christmas Lights Rules Can Be Very Strict
HOA stands for Homeowners Association. These are groups that make rules for neighborhoods. Some HOAs have very strict Christmas lights rules.
The Salgado Family’s Big Problem
The Salgado family lives in Germantown, Maryland. They LOVE Christmas decorations! Every year they put up:
- A handmade manger
- Big inflatable decorations
- Moving decorations (animatronics)
- Lots and lots of lights
Their house is so famous, it’s on Google Maps as a “tourist attraction!” People come from all over Maryland to see it.
But their HOA didn’t like it.
First Year: $3,000 Fine!
Last year was their first year in the Middlebrook Manor South neighborhood. The HOA fined them more than $3,000 for too many decorations!
This year, the family tried to do less. Supuli Salgado (age 19) says they gave away most decorations to a church. They used less than 10% of what they had before.
But the HOA still fined them! This time for $1,100.
The family got a lawyer named David Gardner. He says the HOA is being unfair and “singling out” the family.
Supuli says, “We want to bring joy.” She calls the HOA board members “grinches.”
Are Christmas Lights Rules Legal?
You might wonder: Can the government really tell people what decorations to use?
Sometimes yes, sometimes no.
Colin McDonell was Luttrell’s lawyer. He explains: “The government can’t stop you from expressing yourself based on your message.”
When Rules Are Okay
Christmas lights rules are legal when they:
- Apply to everyone the same way
- Are clear and easy to understand
- Don’t punish certain messages or ideas
- Help with real problems (like safety)
When Rules Are Not Okay
Christmas lights rules break the law when they:
- Let officials decide what’s a “right” decoration
- Are confusing or unclear
- Treat holiday decorations differently than other decorations
- Stop people from expressing themselves
Why Do These Rules Exist?
Cities and HOAs say Christmas lights rules help with:
- Keeping neighborhoods looking nice
- Preventing electrical problems
- Making sure decorations are safe
- Stopping neighbors from fighting
But many people think these rules go too far.
What Can You Do?
If you face problems with Christmas lights rules, here’s what to do:
Step 1: Read Your Rules Carefully
- Check your city laws
- Read your HOA rules (if you have one)
- Know when decorations can go up and down
Step 2: Talk to Officials First
- Explain your situation politely
- Ask questions if rules are confusing
- See if you can work something out
Step 3: Know Your Rights
- Freedom of expression is protected in America
- Rules must be fair and clear
- You can fight unfair rules
Step 4: Get Help If Needed
- Talk to a lawyer
- Contact civil liberties groups
- Connect with neighbors who feel the same way
Famous Quote About Holiday Decorations
Even Taylor Swift sang about this! In her 2019 song “Lover,” she sings:
“We can leave the Christmas lights up ’til January, and this is our place, we make the rules.”
Many people feel the same way. Your home should be your space to celebrate how you want!
The Bottom Line on Christmas Lights Rules
Christmas lights rules are very different across America. Some places have strict laws. Other places let families decorate however they want.
The most important thing is that rules should be:
- Fair to everyone
- Clear and easy to understand
- Respectful of people’s freedoms
If you love decorating for Christmas, check your local rules first. But remember – you also have rights to express yourself and celebrate holidays your own way!
Conclusion: Celebrate the Holidays Your Way
Holiday decorations bring joy to many families. While some Christmas lights rules make sense for safety, others go too far.
Stories like Alexis Luttrell’s and the Salgado family’s show that people are willing to fight for their right to celebrate. Whether you like simple lights or big displays, you deserve to enjoy the holiday season.
Just make sure you know your local Christmas lights rules – and don’t be afraid to stand up if they seem unfair!
Read More : Garth Brooks Lawsuit: Country Star Faces Assault Claims
Reference By : USATODAY
